13  Job Market

Figure 13.1: Futurama Fry meme with the text, “Not sure if I’m highlighting my strengths and character traits for I’m bragging profusely.”

In this section, the focus is on securing a job. The first half will cover using LinkedIn to build your network, while the second half will explore the general steps in the job search process: researching the job market, writing an effective cover letter, acing interviews, and negotiating your salary.

These are my very opinionated answers/advice.

Please note that what I am suggesting will not work for everyone and is based on my experience and some others. I hope they provide some guidance or suggestions to potentially explore. I often advise students and junior staff that it is best to get advice from several people. You will find a common thread among the people that will resonate with you, and you should go with that as a starting point.

13.1 LinkedIn Network

13.1.1 Update your profile

There are a lot of advice pages on what to do to update your profile page. I try to summarize these tips in this section.

  1. Include Professional Photo and Banner Image: The saying “you only get one chance to make a first impression” holds true for your online presence as well. Your professional photo should be high resolution and look polished. Avoid selfies or low-resolution images. If you don’t have a professional headshot, many universities offer free headshot services or host events with professional photographers. Alternatively, you can use AI to generate a photo.
Update your photo every few years

Photos can quickly become outdated, so consider refreshing your professional photo every couple of years. I update mine regularly. Don’t be like my friend who’s still using the photo from my wedding — 10 years ago!

Figure 13.2: Screenshot of Jariulla Safi’s LinkedIn Profile”
Figure 13.3: Photo from my wedding, where Jariullah is my man of honor.

Also, upload a banner image. An empty banner can make your LinkedIn profile look incomplete. If you’re unsure what image to use, think of the banner as a way to reinforce your professional brand. For example, my colleague, Jose Plehn Dujowich’s LinkedIn profile has a banner for his company, where as mine features the image from the cover of my book, which focuses on data privacy. In the past, I used a photo of myself speaking at a conference.

Figure 13.4: Screenshot of Jose Plehn Dujowich’s LinkedIn Profile”
  1. Create a Detailed Headline: LinkedIn automatically populates your headline with your current job title and company. I typically edit it to reflect the title I use in short bios or when introducing myself. However, more and more professionals recommend adding more details, such as relevant keywords, to improve your LinkedIn search ranking. To update your headline, consider highlighting your skills, expertise, or what you want to be known for. Just be sure not to overload your headline with keywords—only include them if it makes sense.
Figure 13.5: Screenshot of Claire McKay Bowen’s LinkedIn Profile”
Figure 13.6: A LinkedIn meme that compares the real life vs. alter ego LinkedIn headline.

Meme from this LinkedIn post.

  1. Write an Executive Summary: Think of your summary as your elevator pitch. It should be a few concise sentences that highlight your professional experience, skills, goals, and background.
My LinkedIn summary

A statistician specializing in statistical data privacy methods, including synthetic data and differential privacy, and their impact on the statistical analysis of economic data. Over 10 years of experience developing both technical and policy solutions with a strong passion for improving science communication and integrating data equity into the data privacy process. Proven track record of leadership, managing teams, and guiding projects that influence policy and data practices.

Figure 13.7: Screenshot of Josh De La Rosa’s LinkedIn Profile”
Executive summary from Josh De La Rosa

LinkedIn Profile Link

Accomplished and award-winning senior researcher skilled in designing research studies and effectively communicating scientific findings. Passionate about modernizing tools, leveraging insights, and employing diverse methodologies to explore data. Natural leader with a talent for project management, team inspiration, vendor coordination, and implementing innovative processes that optimize efficiencies and enhance accuracy in data collection results. 2020 dad of the year.Accomplished and award-winning senior researcher skilled in designing research studies and effectively communicating scientific findings. Passionate about modernizing tools, leveraging insights, and employing diverse methodologies to explore data. Natural leader with a talent for project management, team inspiration, vendor coordination, and implementing innovative processes that optimize efficiencies and enhance accuracy in data collection results. 2020 dad of the year.

  1. Customize Your LinkedIn URL: If you haven’t already, personalize your LinkedIn URL as soon as possible! Customizing your URL can improve your search engine ranking. Make sure it reflects your name or your professional brand. For example, is my last name followed by my first name (e.g., https://www.linkedin.com/in/bowenclaire/). I use this URL on my “Contact Me” slide in presentations and on my personal website.

  2. Update Your Location: Another update you need to make soon is your location, which is one of the top five fields that LinkedIn prioritizes when doing a keyword search. You can update this information in the introduction section.

Figure 13.8: Kermit The Frog Map GIF by Muppet Wiki
  1. Profile Content: The following are ways to improve the content of your profile:
  • List your achievements and skills under each experience section, similar to how they appear on your resume.
  • Include relevant media that showcase your achievements (e.g., a newsletter about an award) and other materials (e.g., links to your projects).
  • Add all skills that are relevant to you and encourage others to endorse them.

13.1.2 How to identify connections

Figure 13.9: Liam Neeson Taken 2 meme with the text, “I don’t know who you are…but I will look you up on LinkedIn, and I will find you.”

Before you start building your network, it’s important to define your goal. Why do you want to grow your network? Possible goals could include:

  • Finding a job
  • Seeking a mentor
  • Showcasing your work
  • Building your personal brand
  • Providing thought leadership
  • Improving sales and services
  • Accessing learning and professional development resources
  • Participating in professional groups
  • Celebrating milestones

Once your goal is clear, it will be easier to identify the right connections. Here are some strategies to get started:

  • Start with your existing network—current and former colleagues, classmates, etc.
  • Identify key stakeholders in your industry or field, such as:
    • Industry leaders
    • Competitors
    • Recruiters
  • Follow companies you’re interested in and individuals who work there.
  • Join relevant groups to stay informed about industry trends, connect with like-minded professionals, and establish yourself as a thought leader.
Figure 13.10: Futurama Fry meme with the text, “Not sure if this is a real person or a bot trying to scam me later.”

13.1.3 How to introduce yourself

Send a personalized message on your LinkedIn requests

I often receive connection requests from bots, so I typically don’t connect with people I don’t know. However, if you send a personalized note, such as “I saw your talk and would love to connect”, I’m more likely to accept your request, even if we’ve never met. A simple message can go a long way. For example, you could write:

“Hi [Name], I’m [Your Name], a student at [School]. I’m interested in [Topic] and came across your profile while exploring the [Industry/Field]. I’m currently looking into career paths in this area and would love to connect to learn more from you.”

These messages should be brief, friendly, and personal (e.g., mention something specific from the person’s profile to make it more engaging).

More information and examples on how to introduce yourself can be found here.

13.1.4 How to engage with those connections

Figure 13.11: So I Guess You Can Say Things Are Getting Pretty Serious meme with the text, “A recruiter added me on LinkedIn. So I guess you can say things are getting pretty serious.”

Again, how you engage with the connections you create depends on your goals. Some students send a followup to learn more about a certain company or job position. Others want to discuss possible project collaborations.

For the former, I’ve had several students ask for informational interviews about working at the Urban Institute. For the latter, I’ve had someone reach out after a conference to see if our two respective companies would like to collaborate on a few proposals on AI.

Another way to engage with your connections is to regularly share resources, professional updates, and insights. For me, I frequently share job postings. The original content I create are letting people know about a recent publication (e.g., an article about women in endurance sports), promoting an event (e.g.,a talk at the Joint Statistical Meetings), or sharing professional connections (e.g., post about the Joint Statistical Meetings and Federal Committee on Statistical Methodology Conference).

13.1.5 Practice

Improving Your Profile and Building Your Network

Objective: To update LinkedIn profiles and send connections to grown professional network.

  1. Review and update your profile (5 minutes): Go to your LinkedIn profile, make at least one improvement to the page. It can be based on what you learned today or something you’ve been meaning to update or change on your profile, but haven’t done yet.

  2. Find a Connection (5 minutes): Find someone new to connect you fits your general goal for being on LinkedIn. Remember the tips we learned about finding new people.

  3. Comment on a Post: If you have extra time, make at least one comment on a post from a LinkedIn connection. If you didn’t have extra time, try to do this after today’s session to help grow your network.

13.2 On the job market

The following are questions my students asked me that pertain to being on the job market.

13.2.1 How do you explore new job opportunities…

while being respectful of your current employer and avoiding the “grass is greener” syndrome?

We will break down the answer to this question in four parts.

  1. Keep your materials up-to-date: Start by updating your resume, LinkedIn profile, and other professional materials. Personally, I update my CV/resume about every month, typically during the first week. In my field, it’s common to have an updated CV for grant and contract applications. If you regularly maintain your resume or professional social media presence, it won’t raise suspicions with your employer.

  2. Think about why you are seeking another opportunity: Reflect on the key reasons for wanting to leave your current position. Is it a temporary annoyance, or is it a systemic issue that, if unresolved, will continue to affect your happiness?

    For example, one of the most common reasons for leaving a job is having a difficult supervisor. Even if you enjoy your work, colleagues, and company, a bad supervisor can be a compelling reason to leave. Supervisors play a crucial role in advocating for key changes on your behalf, finding professional opportunities, and advancing your career. They are often responsible for your raises and promotions. Without a supportive supervisor, your career may stagnate or become difficult to advance.

  3. Schedule interviews outside of work hours: When scheduling interviews, try to arrange them outside of your work hours. It is unethical to use work time for interviews. Some people take time off, make up the hours later in the day, or schedule interviews outside of their regular work hours.

  4. Wrap up your projects neatly: As a supervisor who oversees several people, my biggest request before someone leaves is that they wrap up their projects and responsibilities neatly. This means leaving clear instructions, passing on knowledge, and identifying someone who can serve as a backup until a new person is hired. Additionally, take on quick tasks that can be completed before your departure to help your colleagues with bigger projects.

    For example, one of my team members who helped managed my largest projects was leaving for graduate school. I had already identified a new person to take over her responsibilities. I asked the departing employee to train the new person, clean up the project directory, create read-me files or instructions for each subdirectory/responsibility, and meet with the new person to walk through those materials and responsibilities.

Unpopular opinion: Proceed with caution!

I once received advice to apply for a job occasionally (e.g., once a year) even if you are happy with your current position. Applying for new positions informs you about how competitive your skills are in the job market (i.e., what you are worth). You may learn something new about yourself or what you value. You may also discover an even better opportunity than you currently have.

13.2.2 What are the key elements of a good cover letter?

Figure 13.12: First World Problems meme that says, “They want a cover letter. Now I can’t apply for the job.”

It goes without saying that most people (myself included) do not like writing cover letters. However, a good cover letter is important and should be customized to the job, highlighting how your experiences align with the job description. A cover letter typically has the following structure:

  • Formal greeting: The greeting is usually to the hiring manager to the hiring committee (if known). If unknown, you can use something generic like “Dear Hiring Manager.”

Dear [Hiring Manager’s Name or Group],

  • Introduction: The first paragraph or few sentences should state the position you are applying for, mention how you found out about the job opening (this is nice to know as the hiring manager), and provide a brief statement about why you are interested in the position or the company.

I am excited to apply for the position of [Position Name] at [Company Name] that was posted on [Where You Found the Job Posting]. With my background in [Your Field or Industry] and experience in [Relevant Experience], I am excited about the opportunity to contribute to your team.

  • Or you could have the following for the last sentence.

Please accept this letter and my resume as my application for the position.

  • Body Paragraphs: The next two or three paragraphs should highlight your most recent and relevant experiences and how they match the job posting. Be specific! Simply stating that you are “organized” or “a good communicator” does not demonstrate this to the hiring manager. Provide specific examples from your experience to illustrate these qualities.

I feel that my qualifications are well matched to the posted job description and requirements. I am seeking an opportunity to challenge and build upon my knowledge and experiences. At present, I am [Role, Responsibilities, Skills, etc.]. This experience has equipped me with the skills necessary to [Relevant Experience].

  • Usually in second to last paragraph, you want to say why you are good fit for the company and why you are interested in that company.

My experiences, skills, and drive have prepared me to be an invaluable contributor to the [Company]. Moreover, being a part of [Company] would be ideal for my career as it would [Your Professional Goal and Alignment with Company Values/Mission].

  • Closing paragraph: This paragraph should reiterate your interest in the position, mention how to find more information (if not already stated at the beginning), explain how they can contact you for next steps, and thank the hiring manager for considering your application.

I am eager in taking the next step in this process, please feel free to contact me by phone or email. I appreciate you taking the time to review my application, and I look forward to hearing from you soon.

  • Another example.

I am excited to bring my skills and experience to [Company]. I have attached my resume for your review and would love the opportunity to discuss further how my background, skills, and certifications will contribute to your team. Thank you for considering my application.

Heavily edit AI cover letters!

If you’re going to use AI like ChatGPT to write your cover letter, make sure to heavily edit it afterward. AI is a tool, not a crutch. I’m currently reviewing job applications, and I can easily tell which ones were created with AI. The bonus for me is knowing which applicants to ignore.

This isn’t to say you shouldn’t use AI. HR and other companies are obviously using AI to filter applicants, so why not use the tool to help you? However, as I said, don’t just generate the cover letter without editing it to add your own voice. One of the applicants my colleague and I invited for a phone screen stood out mostly due to her cover letter being so unique and thoughtful.

13.2.3 What are some tips for interviewing well?

Figure 13.13: Dwight Schrute meme that says, “Am I ready for this interview? False. Is this interview ready for me?”

Here are some general tips:

  • Research your interviewers (if you know who they are). They will likely look you up, so it’s only fair you do the same. One candidate impressed me by reading a couple of my papers and sharing his thoughts during the interview.

  • Prepare an introduction about yourself that is concise, with a longer version ready if asked to elaborate.

  • Research the company and be ready to explain why you’re applying for the role and why you want to work for the company.

  • Dress appropriately and arrive on time if the interview is in person. For virtual interviews, ensure good sound quality, a suitable background, proper lighting, and a functioning camera. First impressions matter, even on video calls.

Figure 13.14: Two people shaking hands from the TV Show, “The Office.”
Practice your handshake

If you feel your handshake isn’t strong, consider practicing it with family, friends, or anyone willing to provide honest feedback. I understand it can be challenging for men, as they may worry about exerting too much pressure on women’s hands. However, women have the advantage in this regard, as we are less likely to apply excessive force. So, don’t hesitate to give a firm handshake!

  • Take your time if needed. It’s okay to say, “Can I have a moment to think about this question?” before answering. It’s better to gather your thoughts than to give a rushed or repetitive answer. Interviewers appreciate clear and concise responses.

  • Speak clearly and confidently. If the interview is on video or in person, try to smile and show enthusiasm, even if you’re nervous. Some roles require strong public speaking skills.

  • Prepare your own questions for the interviewer. Remember, you’re also interviewing them!

  • Follow up with a thank-you note reiterating your interest in the position.

Take notes on how your interviewers responded to your questions

When I was on the job market after graduate school, I had a set of questions I loved asking interviewers. I would note their responses so that I could mention them in my follow-up thank-you email. I found that many of them would respond and comment on my email.

13.2.4 How to negotiate salaries?

Before delving into salary negotiations, it’s essential to research the typical salary range for the specific role and responsibilities, taking into account the geographical location. Professional societies such as the American Statistical Association conduct surveys among their members, gathering valuable salary data. Additionally, consider reaching out to friends and family occupying similar positions, if they’re willing to share their salary information. While discussing salaries is often considered taboo, breaking this silence can be empowering for employees, rather than solely benefiting employers.

Many employers are obligated to disclose salary ranges, although some ranges may not be ideal (e.g., very wide). As a hiring manager, understanding your salary expectations is crucial, as it enables me to gauge whether my company can offer a suitable salary within that range (bearing in mind that I have limited control over the predetermined salary bands). This ensures that neither your time nor mine is wasted, minimizing frustration for both parties involved.

When presented with a salary offer, whether verbally or written, it’s advisable not to immediately accept or reject it. If the offer is verbal, take a moment before responding, expressing gratitude for the offer without revealing your opinion on its adequacy. You should mull over the offer for at least a day, carefully considering the other benefits such as vacation time and healthcare provisions in addition to the compensation.